5 Comments

I was also a DJ at a college radio station for four years in the late 90s. I came in with a distinct lack of appreciation for 80s music of all stripes, and the station’s programming brought me to love and respect the Smiths and tons of other acts of the era. I don’t say this in an effort to be a snob about it at all, but it’s just very hard to believe that your station existed in some alternate universe without this. What did they play?

Expand full comment

Fair question. I think a couple of factors played a role in me not knowing about certain legacy acts from the '80s and early '90s:

- I was born and raised in a relatively small market, so the diversity of radio stations was not great. It's still not.

- I grew up in a house where we listened to standards from the '60s and '70s, so my musical knowledge is far wider in those areas than the average 40-something.

- I was a DJ from early 1998 to 2001, and it was a station whose rotation was heavily focused within a year of the air date. I will likely share some super-deep cuts from those years when the time comes, but because of the modern focus, we didn't have a big "recurrent" or "oldies" section, and by that time, the "oldies" were tracks from "Dookie" and "Superunknown" and "Siamese Dream."

- It's possible there were niche specialty shows that catered to tracks from the early '90s, but I generally didn't listen.

- In the late '90s, CDs were priced stupidly high, so the gateway for entry into a new band was pretty high. And my circle of friends, many of whom are still my close friends today, just don't have an interest in music beyond a pop-mainstream appreciation, so I didn't have anyone to swap albums or mix tapes with.

Streaming services really opened the door to much older bands and music for me. I've been playing catch-up on decades of music, and finding lots of songs and acts that are new to me but have been beloved by many more for a lot longer. This Substack came about to force myself to dive deeper into acts I didn't already know, or had heard of but haven't listened to yet.

Expand full comment

“Girlfriend in a coma, I know

I know, it's serious”

Instant fan….

Expand full comment

It's a terrific track, for sure! It's pretty much impossible to find a bad track in the 20 listed on the Billboard link.

Expand full comment

Interesting, thanks for explaining. The original article makes it sound a little like you couldn’t believe that anyone couldn’t believe that you grew up in a Smithsless universe. Our environment shapes our cultural intake so drastically.

I spent most of my high school years listening to metal and grunge and didn’t move to the “alternative rock” station until like 1994 (there was a national format called “Z Rock” that very suddenly decided to switch to country. I turned it on one day to hear “The River” on repeat). So all those Smiths and New Order and Depeche Mode songs were the recurrents. I didn’t much care for them at the time, as they sounded “old” and had way too many keyboards (blecch). Then when I was a college freshman in 1995, I get to the radio station to find all the alt-rock radio songs from 1989-1994- a lot of the stuff you’ve been covering on this site- filling the playlist. I didn’t know a lot of these songs, as I hadn’t been listening to that radio format at the time they were current, and so I had to learn to like them. I remember thinking Jellyfish was the worst thing I’d ever heard. Later on that changed!

Expand full comment